Penny Loafers Café

I had an iced coffee with buttered rum flavor and all the fixings! It was delicious! I also got the biscuits and gravy. The price point was perfect and the taste was divine! I could have had a double order because it was so good. It came with two biscuits for $3.25. I HIGHLY recommend stopping by if you're in the area. The owners are super kind and didn't mind my toddler running around at all. They were very nice, and I enjoyed the pleasant conversation. The food is made from local ingredients as well. They're only open for a few hours from Tuesday to Saturday, so make sure to take that into account. It's absolutely worth it.

On a random stop to explore the area that we usually just drive through, we found some fun places to explore. Penny Loafers Cafe popped up as I looked for a breakfast spot and, though the description seemed to promise too much for the rustic surroundings, once e stepped inside, I realized this place could deliver the goods. The owners were working the window and familiar with the regulars. We sat near a table celebrating a birthday and soon were caught up in the fun and chatting with locals like we were old friends. The food was spot on and delicious while the drinks were over-the-top delicious. Lots of cute trinkets available for sale. On top of it all, they are involved with helping the Lakota tribe. Make sure you put this on your list.

Absolutely love this place! The food and coffees were great and inexpensive. The people who run the place were so friendly. They have a lot of other things for sale also like soaps, candles and even guitar straps!

Kitchen the size of my closet and the coffee tasted like it was stored in my kid's closet. They use those cheap coffee flavors to hide the terrible coffee taste and then charge you like premium prices. The food is just okay but $10 for a tiny rueben that cost them less than $1 to make is ridiculous.

Stay away. This place won't least long

We loved Penny Loafers Cafe! The food was delicious and affordable. The owners were welcoming and very warm. They were able to sit a party of six immediately and the service was quick. We enjoyed shopping the local fare displayed throughout the Cafe as well. We definitely will be back for more!

This was our first time in Mammoth Springs and we stopped at Penny Loafer Cafe first thing. The Reubens was delicious and the almond joy coffee was wonderful. Definitely will go back there before we leave.

Excellent food at reasonable prices. Chicken and beef are sourced from the Amish. There are numerous canned items (relishes, chow chow, jams, jellies, barbecue sauce, pickled eggs, pickled beets, other pickled vegetables - sourced from the Amish), Tshirts, coffee cups, tea towels and other assorted items. They also make specialty coffees. Tea is made fresh as you order it. This is a great place to eat and also buy gifts.

Great little cafe just off the main drag! We enjoyed a French dip and a grilled chicken sandwich. The bread and butter pickles were delicious and the fries were just the right amount of crispy! Next time I'll have to save room for beignets.

I love Penny Loafers! Great great food friendly faces I eat there almost every day. Have a grilled chicken sandwich and some frenchy fries you won’t be disappointed.

I come here on the regular everyday several times a day sometimes the coffee is so awesome I have been known to save the cups in the fridge just so I can have it when they r closed gotta have the peppermint mocha frap!!!!