Search

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Shetler's Cafe Reviews - 100

4.4
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Myron Jackson

The food was okay at shetlers. We were having the salad and soup bar Saturday evening around 6. The problem is the soup looked like it had been sitting around since lunchtime. Although it tasted okay it wasn't particularly warm which was a concern for bacteria growth. One of the soup urns was just about empty. A few of the items on the salad bar were empty. There was only iceberg lettuce for the salad. The service was excellent. The acoustics in the restaurant make it difficult to have a pleasant meal with conversation.

Amy P

What an unexpected surprise! This has to be one of the best burgers I've ever had! Try the Signature Melt, you will not be disappointed. The toasty cheddar bread with melted cheese and a perfectly cooked hamburger with fried jalapenos and onions is fantastic! You will not be disappointed.

Linda Neufeld

Shetler's has a fresh, well kept salad bar- which I can't resist. Our family loves to eat here. The Shetlers Signature burger is a favorite of my husband's. The honey BBQ wings are wonderful! And the Garlic Parmesan. Definitely recommend eating here- it has a cozy atmosphere on a winter day.

donita retz

Very good food. Buffet $11.49 ea. We went on a Friday and it was catfish, hush puppies, fried potatoes, corn on cob, fried chicken, salad and much more. It was delicious!

heather rajski

The cafe is a great place to eat and visit. But they need to bring the bar back and their food is so salty they r going to give someone a heart attack.They also need a bigger menu.

Gabriel Saraceno

Great food. One MUST take the time to stop here. Won't be disappointed!

Julie Danielson

Wow, this food was INCREDIBLE and so affordable! The homemade cheddar bread is a MUST.

Tamara Arrington

awesome food, great prices, friendly staff.

Amy Schiess

Great service, food was homemade! Good prices!

Becky Howe (Howe 2 Homestead)

Really nice folks! Really great breakfast on Saturday morning. It is hard to get a well done baked potato. My husband is partial to the fried chicken. They have a buffet dinner which my son really enjoyed. Family friendly place come on in at seat yourself.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload